Arrows Pick Up Bonus Point in New York Defeat

16 March 2019

BROOKLYN, NY – The Toronto Arrows accrued a valuable away bonus point in the club’s 24-21 loss against Rugby United New York on Friday night.

New York earned the comeback win on the heels of a last-second try at MCU Park.

Toronto had the early momentum in the match, with the visiting side jumping out to an early 6-0 lead through two penalty goals from fly-half Sam Malcolm; the first was struck with gusto from nearly 50 metres out, while the second came as a chip shot just outside New York’s 22. 

The hosts responded minutes later on their first spell of possession in Toronto territory, with hooker Dylan Fawsitt scoring off a rolling maul from a lineout.

The Arrows answered back through scrum-half Andrew Ferguson, who capitalized on a lengthy period of sustained pressure when he found a gap in New York’s defensive line to cross over.

New York added its second try of the match on the final play of the first half, scoring a carbon copy of its first. Again, it was Fawsitt crossing over following a driving maul off a lineout to put the hosts ahead 12-11 heading into the interval.

Similar to the first half, Toronto were the more inspired side out of the gates at the restart. The visitors were first on the scoreboard through a piercing run from Guiseppe du Toit six minutes into the second half, who was set up by a deft popped pass from Malcolm.

The Arrows appeared to have scored again in the 52nd minute after a well-worked give-and-go between Gaston Mieres and Kolby Francis sprung the Uruguayan, but the referee called the try back back after adjudging one of the passes to be forward. The drive still resulted in points for Toronto, as Malcolm kicked his third penalty goal minutes later to increase Toronto’s lead to nine points.

The final 15 minutes of the match featured consistent pressure from the home side, forcing the Arrows into extended periods of try-line stands as the visitors looked to hold on to their lead.

After multiple phases inside Toronto’s 5m area, New York lock Nate Brakeley broke the levee in the 70th minute to reduce the deficit to four points.

Going right back to work deep in Arrows territory, flanker John Quill completed New York’s comeback with a match-winning try on the final play of the game.

“This was a tough one for us to swallow,” said Arrows Director of Rugby Chris Silverthorn. “We dictated the pace of play for the bulk of the game, but lost our composure in the late stages of the match, and that’s when it counted the most. We had a lot of impressive periods of play throughout the game, and earning a road bonus point is certainly important, but we came here looking for the win, and to fall just short is a tough result.”

Entering the match on just four days’ rest, Silverthorn praised his side’s workrate.

“It’s been a gruelling travel schedule for us this week, having gone from San Diego to Toronto to New York all in just a few days, and our guys left it all on the pitch,” added Silverthorn. “We’ll have a well-deserved break coming into the bye week to give our players an opportunity to recover both physically and mentally, and then shift our focus to our final road game against Utah at the end of the month.”

The defeat drops Toronto’s record to 3-4-0, and keeps the expansion club at sixth in league standings with 17 points. New York’s win vaults the fellow league newcomers to the top of the table with a 5-1-0 record and 23 points. 

Friday’s game was the seventh of eight consecutive away matches for Canada’s first professional rugby union team. Toronto’s extended road trip will be followed by eight consecutive home matches between April 7 and June 2 to close out the club’s regular season.

The Arrows have a bye week next weekend, and enter round 10 of the season with an away match against the Utah Warriors on Sunday, Mar. 30.


Toronto Arrows Score Report

Tries: A. Ferguson (26), G. du Toit (46)
Conversions: S. Malcolm (47)
Penalty Goals: S. Malcolm 3 (4, 10, 58)

Rugby United New York Score Report

Tries: D. Fawsitt 2 (13, 39), N. Brakeley (71), J. Quill (80)
Conversions: C. Mattina 2 (14, 80)

Toronto Arrows Lineup vs. Rugby United New York

1. Rob Brouwer
2. Andrew Quattrin
3. Morgan Mitchell
4. Mike Sheppard
5. Paul Ciulini
6. Lucas Rumball (C)
7. Peter Milazzo
8. Jack Nay
9. Andrew Ferguson
10. Sam Malcolm
11. Dan Moor (C)
12. Guiseppe du Toit
13. Spencer Jones
14. Gaston Mieres
15. Shawn Windsor

16. Steven Ng
17. Tom Dolezel
18. Cole Keith
19. Tom Van Horne
20. Kolby Francis
21. Riley Di Nardo
22. Jamie Leveridge
23. John Sheridan

Vice President & General Manager: Mark Winokur
Director of Rugby: Chris Silverthorn
Coaches: Aaron Carpenter, Cory Hector, Peter Smith
Performance Analyst: Rodin Lozada
Team Physicians: Dr. Anthony Dixon, Dr. Chris Gallimore, Dr. John Gillis
Athletic Therapist: Perry Fan

About Toronto Arrows Rugby Club:

The Toronto Arrows Rugby Club is Canada’s first professional rugby union team.

Competing in Major League Rugby, the team is equipped to compete against top-tier North American club teams, providing emerging Canadian talent with enhanced and more frequent opportunities to hone their skills at an elite level.

For more information, visit 


For more information, please contact:

Brock Smith
Communications Manager
Toronto Arrows

Stay Updated:

Want to receive further information regarding Toronto Arrows tickets, merchandise, and latest news? To subscribe to the Arrows club newsletter, sign up below.

Toronto Arrows Privacy Policy

Header Photo Credit: Dave Snook

Our Proud Sponsors & Partners


waypointlandings group


GoodmansLogoColour-centre     Elite Training Systems    aedelhard

Game-Star-Logo  360centre360_logo_cmyk_buffer  xblades_buffer   The_Rugby_Shop_Horizontal_with_Shield_PNG_1_1080x-buffer BigRock_Logo_Vertical_Black-Red_White lostcraft-logo-with-word-goldsaulter

dineen  IrishEmbassyPubGrill   quinns_wOneClover_logo_wGreenBkg_RGB   Nanda Logo Master  Hemingways Logo March 2016 (1)

Toronto_BlueLogo-tall  YorkULogo_Hor_rgb   Xoomler4     560x292


Become a Sponsor


Official Broadcaster



Associated Sports & Community Organizations

rugbyCanadamajorLeagueRugbyrugbyOntariorugbyalliance Social media - TIRF logo


Privacy Policy
Copyright © Arrows Holdings Limited Partnership

search previous next tag category expand menu location phone mail time cart zoom edit close